The Blog and Tour Schedule of Carlos Celdran. A man who is trying to change the way you look at Manila - one step at a time. Telephone: (02)4844945 Text/Cell:(0920)9092021 or Email: celdrantours@hotmail.com

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

KVETCH! KVETCH! KVETCH!

I don't know where to begin about how upset I am about what is going on in downtown Manila and Intramuros. I heard that the year of the Pig is all about change, but these changes I see are all happening way too fast for me to handle. It truly breaks my heart to see centuries old heritage sites being altered without proper planning and long revered establishments close down to make way for brash commercialism and badly designed real estate projects. Here are a few of those alarming changes that I have to adjust to...

FATHER BLANCO'S GARDEN
For years I heard that the Order of Saint Augustine had elaborate plans to construct an seminary/annex to the museum behind their cloisters in Intramuros, on the site of the former Agustinian Dormitories which was destroyed in the Battle of Manila back in 1945 (above, right). In the last ten years, several plans were drawn up, scale models were made, but nothing ever seemed to go beyond the blueprint stage. Frankly, I thought that construction would never ever push through at all. Or that perhaps before doing so, they would first repair the crumbling bathrooms and rooms of the original museum and rebuild the bell tower (which was destroyed in the earthquake of 1883) before venturing into the construction of a new building within the complex. Apparently I thought wrong. Way wrong.

Just a couple of days ago, while doing my usual spiel about the American Colonial period in the garden (above), I recieved word from San Agustine employees that construction would finally begin at the end of March. Looking around, I also noticed that all the plants lining the bench area had all been uprooted, the gardener had been laid off, and the trees marked for cutting (DENR permit?) in order to begin construction of a two storey building that does NOT really look like the original structure at all. This came as horrifying news for me as I now have to find a new location for the American Colonial period segment of my tour. But that aside, I was willing to grin and bear the inconvenience and transfer my spiel to the upper galleries during the construction period since the annex would eventually be used as a restoration workshop, auditorium, and exhibition hall for San Agustin. Truth be told, I am not one to hinder any project that would upgrade the facilities of the museum. But unfortunately that wouldn't be the case either as even the purpose of the new building has been changed. No longer will the building be used for cultural purposes but it will now be used by priests as their domitories and nothing else. I don't know if the National Historical Institute approved these new changes (or if they even know what is going on at all). All I know is that the design needs some major alterations (the glass windows are just way too big and inappropriate) and the museum should definitely be given priority. After all, the San Agustin Order has a lot of land in the province, why don't they build the dormitories out there where the air is fresher and there is more space? It just doesn't make sense to me to build a seminary inside the current San Agustin compound.

The building plans...
This will remain.
But all the trees here will be cut down to make way for the new L shaped seminary.

But you know what else doesn't make sense to me? These structures being built next to Fort Santiago. Huge ugly badminton courts/warehouses being built right on the site of the former golf driving range. It's too big, it's too close to the walls of Fort Santiago, and it just ruins the sanctity of the Jose Rizal Shrine (from where the photo was taken).

And unlike the seminary of Father Blanco's garden (which only suffers from a bad design and a misdirected purpose), these structures above are completely ILLEGAL. Built very close to the walls, this project, worth PHP85M, was pursued despite the disapproval of the Philippine Tourism Authority Board and a stoppage order issued by the Intramuros Administration. Obviously, P.D. 1515 or any adherence to the legal system is ignored here.

To learn more about the law which protects Intramuros, log on to this site.

So to all fellow Filipino citizens (and most especially PRESS PEOPLE), if you wish to do more research on these matters or if you wish to file a complaint illustrating your disgust with these issues, shoot out a scathing email to the following folks.

National Historical Institute
nhi@ideal-access.ph

Ambeth Ocampo - Chair NHI
aocampo@ateneo.edu
oc@ncca.gov.ph

Dominador C. Ferrer Jr.
Administrator
Intramuros Administration
Palacio del Gobernador Building,
Intramuros, Manila 1000
5273155; 5275642; 5273084

Atty. Trixie Cruz-Angeles - Legal NCCA
trixiecruzangeles@yahoo.com

AND MOST OF ALL!!!
Sec. Joseph Ace Durano - Secretary of the Department of Tourism
jadurano@tourism.gov.ph

Really Ace. What the hell? Too busy now acting as the mouthpiece for the Unity Team to give a sh** about Intramuros? Throw us a bone here. You freaking ignored Intramuros for the last two years. Now is a good opportunity to redeem yourself.

Forward this post to your friends and colleagues whom you believe cares for the protection and proper development of Intramuros. I really hope it isn't too late.

Next:
ADIOS HOBBIT HOUSE
GOODBYE SALA RESTAURANT
GOODBYE LIBRARY, FAB, AND KOREA HOUSE
GOODBYE QUIRINO GRANDSTAND BREAKWATER

12 Comments:

Blogger kiko said...

sad indeed. don't they know that there are people out there who'll actually pay to see and experience something old. i realised that when i went to one of your tours last december. i longed to see and know the old manila. back when the city was pristine and glorious. manila's charm is still there. evident in the old structues like intramuros, which unfortunately some people don't respect.

good luck to you carlos. i'm looking forward to attending your other tours when i go home again. and to those bastards, #*(< ^@-!

6:13 PM  
Blogger Senor Enrique said...

Very sad.

7:06 PM  
Anonymous gracing said...

That's just disgusting! I actually saw some construction last time I was in Intramuros in Dec but there wasn't much yet. Surely there are other (better) locations for badminton courts / warehouses and yes, a seminary! (like Tagaytay where there are heaps, right?).

Anyway, no press contacts for me but will push friends and family to take action! Hopefully they will listen to the public.

10:00 AM  
Blogger kiko said...

by the way, i posted a very belated review of your tour. pease forgive my meager writing skills. thanks gain for the wonderful time.

5:20 PM  
Blogger carlotta said...

as if seeing mcdonald's and starbucks in intramuros isn't bad enough. what's happening there now is terrible. intramuros is one of my favorite places to get lost in manila, in history and what's left of our culture. i'd hate to see what happens next.

i'm just glad i got to join your intramuros tour september of last year. love it love it love it love it. =)

6:17 AM  
Blogger Katrina said...

This is just horrible. :-( Good thing I FINALLY got to join your Intramuros tour last year before this happened. Makes me think I really ought to take your other tours already, before those are affected too.

Wait...Sala is closing?! I haven't been in many years, I should return before it disappears too. UGH, Nakpil has become SO seedy. And Hobbit House too??? I can't believe that will now exist just in Boracay, of all places. How I miss the Malate from years ago.

2:06 PM  
Anonymous Tom said...

Travelling and visiting other places is all about experience the sense of the place visited. Or as a leading researcher on tourism postulated it: '... the tourist gaze or focus is directed to features of landscapes and townscapes which seperates them off from everyday experience (URRY, 1990:3).'

I ask myself how do tourism responsible in Manila want to create in Manila (City of Manila) a unique urban experience if they destroy the uniqueness of the Filipino-Spanish heritage by building such construction next or in the middle of a national monument like Intramuros. And even the Church is not aware about uniqueness of its heritage.

'Since tourism involves a serious of individual experiences businesses are attempting to ensure each is a positive 'moment of truth (CARLZON, 1987; cited in MULLINS:5). Interactions (of planning responible) and their 'moment of truth' will occur in public places and in public facilities (MULLINS, 1997:5)

If we reflect on the words above we must ask how does Manila wants to make a difference in South-East Asia to compete with tourism or visitor magnets like Hong Kong or Singapore or even Bangkok. By destruction of the unique Filipino-Spanish heritage in the region. If badminton halls are the response of planners and marketing strategists, Manila will fall far behind other urban tourism destinations in the region. It's 5 minutes before 12 to safe the remains of what could be a tourist and visitor magnet in the region of South-East Asia but the responsible must wake up now to safe it. Otherwise tourist and visitor flow will bypass Manila in the future.

(CARLZAN, J. (1987): Moments of truth:New strategies for today's customer driven economy; MULLINS, P.E. (1997): Quality Management in urban tourism; URRY, J. (1990): THe tourist gaze.)

9:28 PM  
Blogger spanx said...

carlos,


at the very least, can we organize a mini-rally or picket line, if only for a day?

we can invite our friends from the media to cover it.

this is really really really depressing me.

i still mourn the loss of the old jai alai building,
and, pun intended, this is an affront on the sensibilities of true citizens of our city.


just say when, bro.

11:07 PM  
Blogger ivanhenares said...

Hi Carlos, you forgot to mention the proponent of the sports complex project... DEAN BARBERS! He should be fired!

10:56 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I cant believe they are reconstructing the church. I went there two years ago and it was so beautiful. Retrofitting is one thing, but adding to a preserved historical church is another. They should build the seminary somewhere away from the hustle and bustle of Manila, so the priest can concentrate and do their job, Hellar! Let Intramuros be Intramuros! Historic sites shall prevail.

11:40 AM  
Blogger amateur misanthrope said...

Can't they build elsewhere. Landed ang mga pari, di ba?

11:05 PM  
Blogger Alexis said...

I was the one who emailed you the other day. I just saw this entry today.


So sad.


And I love history. I'm taking up history as my major, in fact. As a major history buff, this news hurts even more.

7:35 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home